Judge overturns California's ban on same-sex marriageBy the CNN Wire StaffAugust 4, 2010 4:57 p.m. EDT STORY HIGHLIGHTS Judge rules Proposition 8 is unconstitutional Advocates, opponents of same-sex marriage say the case will likely be appealed RELATED TOPICS Proposition 8 U.S. Supreme Court (CNN) -- A federal judge in California has knocked down the state's voter-approved ban on same-sex marriage, ruling Wednesday that the state's controversial Proposition 8 violates the U.S. Constitution.
Chief U.S. District Judge Vaughn Walker found in his ruling that the ban violated the Constitution's equal protection clause under the 14th Amendment.
The closely watched case came some two years after Californians voted to pass Proposition 8, which defined marriage as a union between a man and a woman.
Neither opponents nor supporters of same-sex marriage said before the ruling that it would likely be the last. Both sides said the decision will be appealed and eventually wind up in the U.S. Supreme Court.
:) This opens up more business opportunities for people in the wedding industry Definetly does! I wonder how many couples will be at the courthouses tomorrow to get licenses and such!
The way I see it is LOVE IS LOVE we cant change the relationship they have between each other. In the 50's people said it was wrong for black and whites to get married but if someone said that now we think they are horrible people, whats the difference? Its all judging...
Not regarding the issue of gay marriage but on the issue of overturning votes: What is the point of voting on something if it's going to get overturned anyway? Guess the government will do what they want whether we vote for it or not.
What is the point of voting on something if it's going to get overturned anyway? Guess the government will do what they want whether we vote for it or not.
Guess the government will do what they want whether we vote for it or not.
Personally I'm kind of glad that the majority aren't allowed to vote away the rights of the minority. I don't want any of my rights to be voted away just because enough people don't like something I do/believe.
Bs. Gays shouldn't be allowed to get married. Marriage is a united love between man and woman. If they want to legally be together then they need to create gay couple uniting ceremonies or whatever but the meaning of marriage is between a man and woman!
Bs. Gays shouldn't be allowed to get married. Marriage is a united love between man and woman. If they want to legally be together then they need to create gay couple uniting ceremonies or whatever but the meaning of marriage is between a man and woman!
I am not for homosexuality in any way, shape or form. But, I could really careless about their unions or wanting to get married. They are not hurting anyone by wanting to be married. Let God be their final judge...
It is not right gay people should have NO right getting married. In the end they are all going to hell anyways. very depressing, i know some good loveing gay people.
Bs. Gays shouldn't be allowed to get married. Marriage is a united love between man and woman. If they want to legally be together then they need to create gay couple uniting ceremonies or whatever but the meaning of marriage is between a man and woman!
I would've rephrased that, but yes, I do agree. Marriage is between a Man and a Woman. I have nothing against Gays and Lesbians, you have a right to live your life the way you see fit, BUT there is a sanctity in marriage that only a man and woman can create. My husband said it perfectly; "If it were biologically correct for a man and a man or a woman and a woman to be together, they would have the ability to procreate." IMO.
Marriage was initially a legal contract in which the father essentially sold his daughter to another man. It has morphed over time into what we call it now. My husband and I still view marriage much like a legal contract. Our being married has very little to do with how much we love each other and how committed we are to one another (and we love each other very much and are very committed). That's a completely separate issue. Marriage sets up the legal aspects of our commitment to one another. Medical decisions, money issues, etc. are all handled by the one contract rather than having to deal with several different legal documents that could be contested in court. Why not let homosexuals who are committed to each other and love each other have the same legal rights as other committed couples?
So couples who don't procreate aren't married? or couples who aren't married don't have children?
Obviously, I'm being dramatic but, to me, that doesn't define marriage.
No, that's not true. But you pointed out why people get married, and I only added another valid point. It all just comes down to your personal beliefs. What really infuriates me is that this judge overturned what the VOTERS had decided. These voters decided that a marriage belongs to man and wife, yet a judge overrulled this. What happened to democracy? Why even vote at all if your voice isn't heard?
There are plenty of couples that cannot procreate that are heterosexual. They can adopt children, or do IF just as homosexuals can. Should that be illegal as well? I mean, if you can't have children the old-fashioned way, should you get a divorce? Marriage is not just for having children. It is a union between two people, that love and support eachother and want to spend their lives together, regardless if they want children or not. Who are we to deny them that right?
It is not right gay people should have NO right getting married. In the end they are all going to hell anyways. very depressing, i know some good loveing gay people.
I think it is ignorant to say all gay people are going to hell. Really? How do you know that? Leave the judging to your God.