Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: Cheater

who's talking here?

O G docswife 1
Donny 9
Mommeee Drest 1
B*Bright 3
ALS MommaKitty 2
sofaa 3
*Sarah H* 7
Lebowski 2
LoveMyCrazyLife 1
2Gems4Ever 1
ohhno0o 1
SusseTraume 1
Jay Elle 5
Colonel LizZoo 6
silverlightstar 2
BadMomma 3
Lupe 1
SierraFoxtrot 2
DoctorDonna 1
Hollyer Than Thou 1
♠VivaLaDoll♠ 1
judy 1
That Btch Boss Lady 3
Limbo 11

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Cheater

Once a cheater always a cheater? My husband cheated on me.. and I honestly never thought he would. So I'm thinking I should give him another shot. what do you think?

Once a cheater always a cheater Vote
 
 52.7% (39)
give him another chance Vote
 
 24.3% (18)
other (explain) Vote
 
 23.0% (17)
Limbo --- 16 years ago -

Once a cheater always a cheater? My husband cheated on me.. and I honestly never thought he would. So I'm thinking I should give him another shot. what do you think? 

That Btch Boss Lady --- 16 years ago -

Only YOU will know what you need to do. 

Hollyer Than Thou --- 16 years ago -

It depends on the situation and the people involved. 

Lebowski --- 16 years ago -


Only YOU will know what you need to do. 


Yeah, what she said.

My XH cheated and I left him. It was the right decision for me but not for everyone. 

Colonel LizZoo --- 16 years ago -

You have to deal with the situation in your own way. Meaning maybe you do counseling and try to fix it all or maybe leaving him. I don't know. Good luck though, OP. 

Limbo --- 16 years ago -

Only YOU will know what you need to do.


Yeah I know that. all these f-n circumstances make it hard. Guess I should rephrase the question. In your experience or believe do you think a cheater is always a cheater. 

Mommeee Drest --- 16 years ago -

In your experience or believe do you think a cheater is always a cheater.

No I do not. 

That Btch Boss Lady --- 16 years ago -

In your experience or believe do you think a cheater is always a cheater.

I wouldn't be able to say yes or no being that my husband has never put me in that situation. Sorry that doesn't help, but goodluck. 

*Sarah H* --- 16 years ago -

yes. 

BadMomma --- 16 years ago -

i voted other, i dont believe that everyone falls under the once a cheater always a cheater senario because there could be a minefield of reasons (or excuses) as to how/why it happened and i cant box that up in a simple yes or no answer

i do suggest counselling before you make a decision

goodluck 

Colonel LizZoo --- 16 years ago -

In your experience or believe do you think a cheater is always a cheater. 

Again, it's situational. I tend to believe that, but I know there are lots of couples who make it through the cheating. If my husband cheated, I'd probably have to leave him because I'm not sure I could ever trust him again--whether he ever cheated again or not, but then again, maybe with counseling, I could.

As BadMomma said, I'd look toward counseling first. Good luck, OP. 

Limbo --- 16 years ago -

Thanks guys. I know this is relieving my business but I dont have friends or family so its been really hard to vent. This is my venting. lol 

SierraFoxtrot --- 16 years ago -

If it were me, my views are once you're married, that's kind of a deal breaker. I was cheated on during a relationship, while just dating, and I forgave. I see it kind of as karma, I was a bad girlfriend back in the day... 

2Gems4Ever --- 16 years ago -

In your experience or believe do you think a cheater is always a cheater.

No I do not.


I don't think so either. 

Donny --- 16 years ago -

What's to stop him from doing it again if you take him back? You've already proven to him that he can get away with it and you won't leave...

Just sayin' 

sofaa --- 16 years ago -

The fact that you asked here, in that manor, makes me think that you might not have the maturity to overcome this with him. 

That Btch Boss Lady --- 16 years ago -

What's to stop him from doing it again if you take him back? You've already proven to him that he can get away with it and you won't leave...

Just sayin'


This sounds very familiar. 

B*Bright --- 16 years ago -

I don't believe in "once a cheater always a cheater". Maybe if his past included cheating on every girlfriend he ever had, then I would say "once a cheater..." BUT if he has never had a history of cheating then I doubt he's a serial cheater.

With that said, in your personal situation, it all just depends on what you think. Could you ever trust him again? Did he cheat while things in the marriage were rocky or you were both very happy in the marriage? I ask because in my opinion it seems like if it happened while things were rocky and uncertain (like you had both been fighting and not sure of the relationship) then it might have been a moment of weekness type of thing. It doesn't make it okay but it seems like it wouldn't be a repeat offense that way whereas if you were all great and happy in your marriage and givin it up 15 times a week and he still cheated then it seems like he would be more prone to being a serial cheater. Just because it would seem like he takes you for granted and doesn't respect you very much. But again, this is all how *I* view things....others on here will say I'm crazy and that it would definitely not matter the situation and that cheating is a deal breaker, like SierraFoxtrot said. So again, it all matters what YOU think!


My advice is go to counseling and see if you can work through it. Tell him if he wants to stay married to you then he will go to counseling with you. I would also suggest making him get tested for STD's (and maybe yourself if you have slept with him since the cheating) because some std's don't show signs and symptoms, especially in men. I would have him do it even if he wore a condom because some can still be caught and if he says no then say you won't be sleeping with him any time soon...he messed up, he needs to be SURE he is clean before possibly giving you something if you choose to stay. 

Limbo --- 16 years ago -

I actually agree with Donny and Sofaa.
I guess I'm trying to convince my self other wise because I love him so much.. and we've been through so much.
But that's not an excuse to act that way. 

ALS MommaKitty --- 16 years ago -

I have NEVER liked the "once a cheater always a cheater" statement, because I truly believe people can change. With that said I dont know your situation so I cant say stay with him because there are many factors that would lead to me say whether I believed you could work past it and become stronger. from what you have posted here I dont think that would be possible. 

Donny --- 16 years ago -

People CAN change, but not with the person they cheated on.

The damage is done, the scar always remains and you will always question who/what/where he/she is with in the back of your mind. Once trust is lost it's gone for good. 

Lebowski --- 16 years ago -

The damage is done, the scar always remains and you will always question who/what/where he/she is with in the back of your mind. Once trust is lost it's gone for good. 


Agreed. 

B*Bright --- 16 years ago -

The damage is done, the scar always remains and you will always question who/what/where he/she is with in the back of your mind. Once trust is lost it's gone for good.

Sort of a spin off...

In that case above, that "once trust is lost it's gone for good", would it matter HOW the trust is lost? Or only in cases of cheating? Like, if your spouse lied to you about dipping or smoking or drinking or how and where they spent some money or they started gambling again, etc... Those would definitely put dents in your trust, but would those be deal breakers as well? I mean, they did lie to you so can you not completely ever trust them again that they won't smoke or drink ever again? I'm just curious because I'm dealing with a similar situation (the dipping part) and I don't see it as a deal breaker, but then again, I would give a 2nd chance on a cheater if I believed it could be worked through...So I was just seeing if you had the same thoughts on lying about other things.. 

*Sarah H* --- 16 years ago -

To me putting your penis in someone elses vajayjay is a whollleeeee lot different than smoking/dipping and lying about it. I would be hurt if my husband decided to lie about either but cheating is a deal breaker, no questions asked. 

B*Bright --- 16 years ago -

To me putting your penis in someone elses vajayjay is a whollleeeee lot different than smoking/dipping and lying about it.

Definitely true! I was just wondering though at what point does lying about all the little things equal the same as lying about cheating? 

sofaa --- 16 years ago -

Cheating is not automatically a deal breaker for me, it would depend on circumstances. I know that's not the case for everyone though. I think you need to do what feels right to you and you alone (assuming you don't have kids) 

*Sarah H* --- 16 years ago -

Definitely true! I was just wondering though at what point does lying about all the little things equal the same as lying about cheating? 

Good question. I guess that would vary, but if lying is a constant, even about little things, that would lead me to believe that he would lie about bigger things and thats a deal breaker for me as well. 

ALS MommaKitty --- 16 years ago -

The damage is done, the scar always remains and you will always question who/what/where he/she is with in the back of your mind. Once trust is lost it's gone for good.

I personally dont agree with that, I believe there is always a way to rebuild trust and move on. But for some people its not possible so I wouldn't always suggest to stay since it doesn't work for every personality type. 

sofaa --- 16 years ago -

Once trust is lost it's gone for good.
I disagree. I haven't been cheated on so I can only speculate but I do think that sometimes, that trust is regained. 

SierraFoxtrot --- 16 years ago -

I disagree. I haven't been cheated on so I can only speculate but I do think that sometimes, that trust is regained. 

It definitely depends on the person. And until you've dealt with it, it's hard to say what you would do and how you would feel. I've been cheated on, many times. Not since I was married, thankfully, but I no longer think it will be a problem. Our vows meant something to us. And I intend to hold my husband to them, and I never intend to break mine. 

page 1 2 3
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...

advice

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground