We had a roomate that cause extensive damage(Over $2k worth) and moved out on bad terms. I am meeting up with a mutual friend and am considering giving her a box of the exroomates items that I remember her considering sentimental. They(the ex roomate and her soon to be ex husband) left some things in our garage when they left. I am planning on donating and selling everything else they left.
So the question is, would you give back the sentimental items? My husband doesnt want to because he is still angry for the condition they left our home in. I want to because I would feel wrong keeping something that meant alot to her. I dont think she realized she left it. I am also hoping it will show the mutual friend that I was the victim in this senario. Thoughts?
Well.. I would try. Maybe even just ask the mutual friend if they think the ex roomie wants it. I would try to be the bigger person, because that's just my nature.
I would give it back because two wrongs don't make a right. Maybe you returning the items will make them want to make things right and if not you can be proud for doing the right thing.
We have already paid for most of the damages out of our savings. The rest we will take care of when its time to rent it out(we own the home). Its not worth a whole lot, just some Christmas decorations that I believe was given to her by her mom. I'm just torn because I know how hurt my husband is by how they treated us but I beleive in karma and I always try to do the right thing.
No reasoning other than it is the right thing to do regardless of who it belongs to.
This is my reasoning too. I know I have done some things that are wrong in my lifetime, but you can never get back sentimental items. My mom passed away when I was really young and all of our things were lost in a storage unit my dad didn't pay for when he went to jail. I would give anything to get that stuff back.. I now own nothing that belonged to her.
You'll do the right thing, AJ :) At the end of the day, you have to do what makes you feel right/best. Maybe she wouldn't do the same for you but you are a better person than she is.
Definitely give them back. If you don't, to me, its just giving yourself bad juju in the future. If you know that she would want those items, it shouldn't even be a decision. You can't change other peoples bad actions, but you can make sure you make the right ones.
That is my thinking. She is burning bridges left and right because of her behavior. I would feel wrong selling these things in case something would happen before she came to her senses and built back those bridges.
Maybe she wouldn't do the same for you but you are a better person than she is. Thanks, it doesnt feel like it sometimes. Wondering what I did wrong to cause her to treat me so badly but I cant dwell on that crap.
If you know that she would want those items, it shouldn't even be a decision.
The only thing that makes me think about it is my husband. He doesnt think as clearly as I do when he is upset. But he will get over it. There is still other items we can sell to try to get some of our money back.
They are definitely gonna realise you are the bigger/better person by giving them back, I don't know if I could do it cause I hold grudges, lol, but you're doing the right thing by giving the things back.
Im cautious about that becuase I dont want her asking for the expensive items they left just because she can. She has taken advantage of my kindness in the past and I am determined to not let it happen again. I know she would want it. I will give it to our mutual friend when she comes over tonight. Then I can just be done with it.
As hard as it is to not seek revenge sometimes, it's good to be the bigger person :)
Yea, its really hard. At least some good is coming out of it. I am donating a huge box of thier clothes that i dont want to be bothered to sell to the amvets.
I totally get ur dilema tho because my husband would probably be the same as urs. He is super stubborn and holds grudges like no one I know. So I would have to give those things back without his knowledge probably.
I was going through the stuff and found a very nice vase Im sure was a wedding gift. I included that in the box to give back along with some pictures I think was from thier fridge in their old place. I feel better knowing that that stuff is going back to her.
If it meant a lot to her, she would have made the effort to get it back.
I dont think she knows she left it behind. She moved out in a rush in the middle of the night and a few days later she brought the cops to get back whatever else she wanted. I think she thought it was in the storage unit she had and hasnt had the guts to try to get it back from us.
I personally wouldn't give it back unless she signed for it somehow. What if she uses you giving her that back against you for keeping and selling the other stuff? She already sounds like a great person for moving out in the middle of the night.
What if she uses you giving her that back against you for keeping and selling the other stuff? She already sounds like a great person for moving out in the middle of the night.
I have records of all damages. If she tries to sue for the property I sell/toss/donate I can counter sue for the damages. And yea, bringing her boyfriend with her who I forbade ever come into my home again....she is a real winner.
Definitely give her an itemized list of what she is taking, and take pictures of each item individually and in the box. I hope you're going to meet somewhere away from your house.
Ohh I never want to lay eyes on her again. I have a friend coming over tonight to hang out who is also a friend of hers. I will be giving it to her to deliver. I trust my friend to give it to her.