So I was just at physical therapy on base and I'm pretty sure my physical therapist just called me "fat" with out actually saying it. I asked her what an ideal weight is for me and she said it was just 12 pounds less than what I weigh now... Does 12 lbs classify me as "overweight"?? Pretty sure my self confidence just droped 20 pts. lol
Well since Christmas I have lost 20lbs so I'm not really concerned about it. I'm still in the process of loosing weight, so, at the rate I'm going, by summer I will be at my "ideal weight"
I'm 5'3 and depending on your frame (small, medium, large) 155 is over weight but not obese. I'm sitting at 142, but because I have a small frame, I should be at a minimum 10 lbs lighter
and I also have cancer and have been on chemo and radiation for 2 years, so those also play a bit of a roll in my being overweight. Every woman is different
so you're upset an expert told you an ideal weight (which you asked for), and it happened to be less than what you weigh.
so basically you're just coming on here looking for people to tell you you're not fat.
Some of us have to work harder to be small
I don't think she meant to offend you. And you've already shown amazing dedication by losing 20 lbs. Let the doctor's visit today be motivation to continue on
dano offense, but Im 3 months pregnant, also 5'3 and weigh 127.
damn i wish! you must be tiny when ur not prego. im 5'3'' 120 lbs and im not prego.
samantha- i wouldnt worry about it too much. unless your really unhealthy
I'm not mad at all that my doctor said what she said, and I'm NOT looking for people to tell me I'm not fat. I was fat a few months ago, but I'm happy with my progress, and I'm happy to continue going on with my goal. I was just asking who classifies 12 lbs as overweight...If you do then cool if not that's fine too. I wasn't looking for people to be rude either..
and I also have cancer and have been on chemo and radiation for 2 years, so those also play a bit of a roll in my being overweight.
i thought chemo was supposed to make you lose weight.
so you're upset an expert told you an ideal weight (which you asked for), and it happened to be less than what you weigh.
Sounds like it...
I mean, they're the expert...?
I'm 5'3 and my ideal weight is 120. Am I there?? HA! No. FAAAAR FROM IT! Am i built to weigh more than I do? No. It depends on each person. A doctor/nutritionist would know what is the ideal weight for you. If you ask them a question and they give you an answer, then what's wrong with that?
so 142 is the ideal weight for someone that is 5'3'' so does that mean im underweight??
That would make me pretty underweight too.. and i'm not so I don't see how that can be right lol.
I was just asking who classifies 12 lbs as overweight
Well, 12 lbs off from the ideal weight would be over weight just as much as l lb or 50 lbs would be.
That would make me pretty underweight too.. and i'm not so I don't see how that can be right lol.
It depends on each person and their build. :) I know that I've been told 120 lbs is the ideal weight for me. Am I built for that? No. I'm built for exactly where I'm at. I'm asian. But I would LOVE to fit my jeans better. Lol!
Yeah 12 lbs "overweight" doesn't sound like it would be overweight, but split the word into two and it's over weight. Over the weight that's IDEAL. As long as it works for you or you're built for the weight you're at, I say you're good. But only your doctor knows what's best! :)
im 5'2 and am the same weight and my doc told me a while ago that in a nice way i was fat also. i wanted to cry cause its all baby weight and just have not lost it.
Yeah, I'm not hurt by what she said. Like I said earlier I'm happy with the progress I've made thus far and I'm still working and will continue. Every woman is different and only your doctor can tell you what's healthy for you. I'm very close to my goal and I know I'll be there soon. Just wanted to see what all of you had to say, and maybe get ideas on how to continue loosing weight. Thanks ladies...