Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: Just curious....do you think our militarys pay should....

who's talking here?

Pasha 1
kim 1
Going - Going - GONE! 2
M*bell*my*bell 2
sofaa 2
Lavender is Good 2
DoRkYbRaTt 2
El Doosho 4
WesternGirl 3
Spork Fight 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Just curious....do you think our militarys pay should....

be tax free always or just while they are in a tax free zone?

yes Vote
 
 62.5% (25)
no Vote
 
 20.0% (8)
you're crazy! Vote
 
 12.5% (5)
i don't kow Vote
 
 5.0% (2)
DoRkYbRaTt --- 16 years ago -

be tax free always or just while they are in a tax free zone?  

Spork Fight --- 16 years ago -

your poll makes zero sense... yes always, or yes tax zone? i say yes tax zone. we are americans, and all americans are subject to taxes, no matter the job. the exception being money made out side the us. 

sofaa --- 16 years ago -

Uhh... if you pick yes which are you saying yes to? I'm with sarcasm with a side of b!tch on this one. 

Going - Going - GONE! --- 16 years ago -

your poll makes zero sense... yes always, or yes tax zone? i say yes tax zone. we are americans, and all americans are subject to taxes, no matter the job. the exception being money made out side the us. I *think* what she means is should the military still have to pay taxes here. When they're deployed they don't have to. 

DoRkYbRaTt --- 16 years ago -

But yeah, this poll makes no sense.  ok sorry for making a poll that makes no sense. i was just curious because i was talking to a few people and someone mentioned it so i figured i would ask. since my poll makes no sense then i will lock topic! thanks anyway 

Going - Going - GONE! --- 16 years ago -

ok sorry for making a poll that makes no sense. i was just curious because i was talking to a few people and someone mentioned it so i figured i would ask. since my poll makes no sense then i will lock topic! Al you have to do is make a new poll with but options. Go into more detail with your question and you answers 

kim --- 16 years ago -

should we be taxed in our pay / bonuses when in a tax free zone? is that your question? I think yes we are in America the pay comes form America pay American taxes. 

WesternGirl --- 16 years ago -

I think we should have to pay taxes, but when they go over-seas, it should be tax free....You know, how they have it now. 

Pasha --- 16 years ago -

I think we should have to pay taxes, but when they go over-seas, it should be tax free....You know, how they have it now. I agree. 

Lavender is Good --- 16 years ago -

I think a majority of military families rather than paying taxes actually do not. All the credits at tax time really add up and many along with having no tax burden will end up getting extra back more than they ever paid. My husband is a SSgt and he also got a 20 something k bonus last year and we still just barely got more back because of credits than was ever withheld in the first place. He was deployed for 8 months but in a location that is not tax free since we aren't technically there. I still pay taxes with sales tax, property taxes, and mella roos however. 

WesternGirl --- 16 years ago -

8 months but in a location that is not tax free since we aren't technically there. Oh, thank you for reminding me!! Whether they be on a ship, or in afghanistan and/or other places, it should be tax free if they are deployed to those places. If they are stationed/TAD/whatever else, it should not be tax free. Whatever country they are in, their pay should follow those rules/guidelines. But if they are deployed, all their pay should be tax free. *Edit, hopefully that makes sense, and yes, some of it is already like that. I'm talking in general. 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

Oh, thank you for reminding me!! Whether they be on a ship, or in afghanistan and/or other places, it should be tax free if they are deployed to those places. If they are stationed/TAD/whatever else, it should not be tax free. Whatever country they are in, their pay should follow those rules/guidelines. But if they are deployed, all their pay should be tax free. *Edit, hopefully that makes sense, and yes, some of it is already like that. I'm talking in gener WTF? This still makes no sense. And no, we should not get "tax-free" pay UNLESS we are in a combat zone. That is the way it is now, no need to change it. 

WesternGirl --- 16 years ago -

WTF? This still makes no sense. And no, we should not get "tax-free" pay UNLESS we are in a combat zone. That is the way it is now, no need to change it. What I was trying to say. Except the "Unless we are in a combat zone". I think anyone who is deployed over-seas should get tax free. If their in the states, they should pay taxes. 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

What I was trying to say. Except the "Unless we are in a combat zone". I think anyone who is deployed over-seas should get tax free. If their in the states, they should pay taxes. Why shouldn't they pay taxes if overseas NOT in a combat zone? 

sofaa --- 16 years ago -

I think anyone who is deployed over-seas should get tax free. So like... those in Japan shouldn't pay? Your poor grammar makes you kinda hard to understand, you know. 

M*bell*my*bell --- 16 years ago -

If our pay was tax free then wouldn't that mean we don't get tax refunds? People would be complaining, well people will complain either way right? People can and do elect to not have taxes withheld knowing that between the amount of credits and deductions they will have no tax liability. In regards to the original poll/question. No, whether overseas or state side I believe tax rates should apply to income earned. I don't understand the motive behind the question. What about the life saving physicians or fire fighters? I think what they do is really cool and the later even risk their lives... should they be excluded from federal income tax? 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

ACTUALLY I think ALL of our pay AND ALLOWANCES should be taxed, including BAH, BAS, SDA etc. 

M*bell*my*bell --- 16 years ago -

ACTUALLY I think ALL of our pay AND ALLOWANCES should be taxed, including BAH, BAS, SDA etc.  = higher retirement earnings. Of course it can't be that easy, they'd tack on more years of service or something to justify it all. 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

= higher retirement earnings. Of course it can't be that easy, they'd tack on more years of service or something to justify it all. Retirement Earnings aside. I don't see why we should get that money tax free. 

Lavender is Good --- 16 years ago -

Retirement Earnings aside. I don't see why we should get that money tax free. I agree esp when people start qualifying military for assistance based on base pay alone. Sometimes I think some military families don't realize how good they have it. When you add it ALL up, we have it good compared to most civilians who have worked the same number of years with the same amount of education. Not always, but in general I think the military provides a little better quality of life than otherwise. 

page 1
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground