Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: Are you/your husband ok with someone calling him a Soldier?

who's talking here?

kikomon 1
Pasha 1
O G docswife 2
EastCoast 1
Mrs Patch 2
Heather 1
Thread Killer 1
✧cristina✧ 2
Donnye oregonbound bye camp p 3
San Antonio Bound 1
ALS MommaKitty 2
sofaa 1
*SurroMom2Twins* 4
Abra 2
Lavender is Good 3
El Doosho 11
texasbound 1
βo§§ L@dγ 10
SusseTraume 1
summer1 1
MrsFear 2
Hollaina 1
Kandice 1
Life expansions 1
Starr 1
Red Headed Mamma 1
csusbchick 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Are you/your husband ok with someone calling him a Soldier?

So I got into a discussion with an Army wife about refering to everyone in the Military as a Soldier. To me, everyone in the Marine Corps is a MARINE, everyone in the Navy is a Sailor, everyone in the Army is a Soldier and so on...what do you think? and are you and/or your husband fine with being called a Soldier?

Yes, they're all the same to me. Vote
 
 1.7% (2)
No, they're all in the Military but they are not all Soldiers. Vote
 
 81.7% (94)
I don't care Vote
 
 16.5% (19)
*SurroMom2Twins* --- 16 years ago -

So I got into a discussion with an Army wife about refering to everyone in the Military as a Soldier. To me, everyone in the Marine Corps is a MARINE, everyone in the Navy is a Sailor, everyone in the Army is a Soldier and so on...what do you think? and are you and/or your husband fine with being called a Soldier?  

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

I'm a Marine and I personally don't care what they call me. Just don't call me late for happy hour. As a wife, why should YOU care? Your husband, I can see...maybe. But a wife?? 

*SurroMom2Twins* --- 16 years ago -

I'm a Marine and I personally don't care what they call me. Just don't call me late for happy hour. lol As a wife, why should YOU care? Your husband, I can see...maybe. But a wife?? Yes I care....i'm not crazy about it but I do have an opinion about it. 

✧cristina✧ --- 16 years ago -

To me, everyone in the Marine Corps is a MARINE, everyone in the Navy is a Sailor, everyone in the Army is a Soldier and so on... I agree. However, I don't get offended when people call, say a Marine, a soldier. I don't think everyone knows that each branch calls themselves something differently and not just soldiers, so if someone has a problem with that, they should correct them instead of getting upset about it (I know people that get seriously pissed when someone calls a Marine a soldier). I didn't know Marines weren't called soldiers until my husband enlisted and he told me, so I think there is just a general ignorance sometimes. 

Thread Killer --- 16 years ago -

I honestly don't care. People who know the difference know the difference. But, I would never sit there and correct a child, family member, etc. That is just cruel. Besides, the general definition of a soldier, to a person outside the military community, is someone who serves our country. 

Red Headed Mamma --- 16 years ago -

It drives my husband crazy! He went through boot camp to be a Marine not a soldier! In his words not mine. 

Lavender is Good --- 16 years ago -

It "bugs" me but no more than someone calling the MCX a PX or writing there instead of they're ect. I don't say anything, but my in my mind I can't help noticing and correcting. No malice is intended by using the wrong word just as no malice is intended when someone does not follow grammar rules. 

Donnye oregonbound bye camp p --- 16 years ago -

If someone calls my husband a Soldier i will correct him, because he is a Marine. He didnt go to basic he went to Bootcamp, he wasnt gone for 6 weeks he was gone for 13. And I care because he worked hard for the title Marine so he deserves to be called one. 

βo§§ L@dγ --- 16 years ago -

I don't really truly care. But I will say that I have had the urge to correct them when they say Soldier instead of Marine. However, I did not go through bootcamp or climb the Reaper or go on a deployment so it's not really my place. Though I have been in a conversation with one girl in particular and she would always introduce me as the "Army Wife". I correct her there. I say "My name is.... and I'm married to a Marine, not a soldier. There's a difference" Never fails. She's a ding bat. 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

If someone calls my husband a Soldier i will correct him, because he is a Marine. He didnt go to basic he went to Bootcamp, he wasnt gone for 6 weeks he was gone for 13. And I care because he worked hard for the title Marine so he deserves to be called one. That's cute. 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

"My name is.... and I'm married to a Marine, not a soldier. There's a difference" Never fails. She's a ding bat. What's the difference? 

βo§§ L@dγ --- 16 years ago -

What's the difference? From what I am told bootcamp is longer and harder. Besides if there wasn't then why give them the specific names? 

MrsFear --- 16 years ago -

I personally know the difference and wouldn't call one the other but I wouldn't like go out of my way to correct people... my husband might get annoyed by it but thats him. I don't think everyone knows the difference... What would you call a airforce guy? 

Donnye oregonbound bye camp p --- 16 years ago -

That's cute. i know, i try my best to be cute :P 

kikomon --- 16 years ago -

most people dont know the difference but i will correct them. i do think there is a difference because like someone else said they joined the MARINES not the army or navy. they earned that title just like any other branch of military. 

βo§§ L@dγ --- 16 years ago -

What would you call a airforce guy? Airman? 

Lavender is Good --- 16 years ago -

What would you call a airforce guy? That would be an Airman. 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

From what I am told bootcamp is longer and harder. Besides if there wasn't then why give them the specific names? Coke and Pepsi are both "Colas" but they each carry their own name. Which is better? Depends who you ask. 

βo§§ L@dγ --- 16 years ago -

Coke and Pepsi are both "Colas" but they each carry their own name. Which is better? Depends who you ask. Is this about who's better now? 

csusbchick --- 16 years ago -

I think if you are going to talk about someone at least show enough respect to refer to them by their correct title. You wouldn't refer to a Doctor by anything other than Doctor would you? It's a matter of respect in my opinion. Don't just clump them all together or just say troops if you are going to use a general term. 

βo§§ L@dγ --- 16 years ago -

You wouldn't refer to a Doctor by anything other than Doctor would you? It's a matter of respect in my opinion I was just thinking that. 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

Coke and Pepsi are both "Colas" but they each carry their own name. Which is better? Depends who you ask. Is this about who's better now? Most people that get upset base it on a feeling of superiority. 

Donnye oregonbound bye camp p --- 16 years ago -

You wouldn't refer to a Doctor by anything other than Doctor would you? It's a matter of respect in my opinion exactly. 

βo§§ L@dγ --- 16 years ago -

Most people that get upset base it on a feeling of superiority Ah, well... you asked me what the difference was. I just told you what I'm told, if it's not true then I will eat crow. 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

I think if you are going to talk about someone at least show enough respect to refer to them by their correct title. You wouldn't refer to a Doctor by anything other than Doctor would you? It's a matter of respect in my opinion. But not all Doctors are the same. Some are podiatrists, others Cardioligists, Orthopedic Surgeons etc etc. But we call them all Dr. right? Do you think they get upset and say "No I'm a Cardiologist, not just a Dr".?? 

βo§§ L@dγ --- 16 years ago -

But not all Doctors are the same. Some are podiatrists, others Cardioligists, Orthopedic Surgeons etc etc. But we call them all Dr. right? Do you think they get upset and say "No I'm a Cardiologist, not just a Dr".?? Right, but they earned (most, not all) the title Doctor. Just like a Marine earns the title marine, Rescue swimmers earn the the title rescue swimmer, etc... 

ALS MommaKitty --- 16 years ago -

They are all troops but soldiers are Army, seaman are Navy, airmen are Air Force and Marines are Marines. Have respect for each force and call them their correct name. I'm a stickler on this due to growing up in the Navy and having worn the AF uniform myself. Noone would call my father or myself a soldier why call my husband one. As someone said you wouldn't call a doctor anything but doctor. 

csusbchick --- 16 years ago -

But not all Doctors are the same. Some are podiatrists, others Cardioligists, Orthopedic Surgeons etc etc. But we call them all Dr. right? Do you think they get upset and say "No I'm a Cardiologist, not just a Dr".??  True, not all are the same so 'doctors' would be a generalized term as 'troops' is. So why not just refer to military personnel as 'troops?' Again, it's about respect. As a newsanchor you should be aware of the perception of your viewers. If you're viewers perceive there to be a difference amongst the branches, you should either use a general term or refer to the correct title of the branch you are reporting on. 

Heather --- 16 years ago -

Personally, I dont care. Im a Soldier, my husband is a Marine, but back home, most people back home dont know the difference, and thats ok to us. We dont go around correcting people. 

✧cristina✧ --- 16 years ago -

But not all Doctors are the same. Some are podiatrists, others Cardioligists, Orthopedic Surgeons etc etc. But we call them all Dr. right? Do you think they get upset and say "No I'm a Cardiologist, not just a Dr".?? Anyone with a PhD is also called a doctor, even if it's not in the field of medicine. So the term Doctor is fairly general, kind of like soldier (especially if you go with the actual definition of soldier like Thread Killer said). 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground