Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: Who should control childbirth?

who's talking here?

ALEM 1
O G docswife 1
Vod Kaknockers 1
petit oiseau 1
sofaa 1
Lavender is Good 3
Spork Fight 1
Tits McGee 4
Jay Elle 3
saywhat?! 1
Melissa 1
Lupe 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Who should control childbirth?

This story got my gears a-turning. Who should control childbirth, the mother-to-be or the doctor? Check out the story! [url=http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/38129344/ns/health-pregnancy/]MSNBC[/url]

Doctor - He/She has the medical degrees Vote
 
 12.8% (5)
Mother - She has intuition on her side Vote
 
 10.3% (4)
Depends - Each case is different Vote
 
 76.9% (30)
Tits McGee --- 16 years ago -

This story got my gears a-turning. Who should control childbirth, the mother-to-be or the doctor? Check out the story!

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/38129344/ns/health-pregnancy/ 

Lupe --- 16 years ago -

I read this in SELF (i have a subscription). there are valid points to each. Some women need the doctor, especially, if they have a history of difficult births or if they are at risk for any complications.

My cousin has been diabetic since she was a kid and when she had her first he was in NICU for a few days and then her 2nd the same thing. I couldn't imagine her wanting or thinking she can do this alone just on intuition. Her 2nd was a preemie, almost 2 months early. 

Lavender is Good --- 16 years ago -

It depends. The far majority of cases no medical attention is needed at all, even if we give it anyway. Obviously in a c-sec the mother certainly can't be in charge.

As our medical knowledge has advanced, however, so has the number of interventions in otherwise normal births. Once interventions start to be added risks go up and medical observation becomes more important.

I have had births in which the doctor was not needed at all (and in fact did not show up until after my baby was born), and I have had a birth in which there were complications and medical help was certainly required.

That is what is wonderful about the obstetric medical advancements we have. We are able to only use the ones we need when we need them (or otherwise want). 

Tits McGee --- 16 years ago -

That is what is wonderful about the obstetric medical advancements we have. We are able to only use the ones we need when we need them (or otherwise want).

I.E., Doctors vs. Midwives

IMO, I'd rather have a doctor controlling my labor than doing it on my own. There's a reason they paid all the money to go to all those fancy schools and get all those pretty degrees.
I trust them.
And if a doctor were to get snippy with me or have an "i couldnt care less" attitude BUT THEY WERE DOING EVERYTHING RIGHT, I wouldn't mind as much.
I'd rather have a snippy doctor than no doctor. 

Lavender is Good --- 16 years ago -

I wasn't talking about Drs vs. midwives, I was only referring to things available within a Dr attended birth since that is what your question was regarding.

As for me, I like that I am strong and intelligent enough to control my own labor when possible, and thankful that I had the knowledge of the Dr I chose when it was needed.

eta I don't mean to imply that those who do not want to control their own labor when there are no complications are not strong and healthy. I'm saying that I wanted to, and I accomplished it by educating myself and staying strong. 

Jay Elle --- 16 years ago -

It depends. The far majority of cases no medical attention is needed at all, even if we give it anyway.

Exactly. Women know how to birth by instinct. Alot of people don't realize that, and will just go to the hospital and have it "done". Doctors are not trained in real childbirth. Most have never seen a natural birth. And they are setting you up to get out of that bed as quickly as possible, they need it for other patients, and they want to be home for dinner. If your not moving along fast enough, you will get medicine to get it going. So in a normal childbirth, a woman should be in control. Moving around as she pleases, showering, bathing, resting, whatever she feels she needs to do. If there is something medically wrong, that's the point at which a doctor needs to take over. 

Melissa --- 16 years ago -

It is not the doctors fault that this women had a reaction to the Stadol. She is just looking for something to complain about. After you get a painkiller you have to relax not get all worked up and I think that is what she did. And I highly doubt that it caused her depression. She most likely had postpartum due to her anxiety from before this.
Doctors go to Medical school and know what to do in case of emergency but they do make mistakes. They are not gods. I think it is a balance between the doctor and mother. But some Mothers can be really b*tchy and act like they know all. 

Tits McGee --- 16 years ago -

Women know how to birth by instinct.

I agree with that.
But look back 100 years ago at the rate of how many women &/or newborns died during childbirth because they either did it alone or with the limited knowledge the doctors had back then.
Then look at todays. 

Lavender is Good --- 16 years ago -

Apples and Oranges.

You can't compare a mother trying to maintain control of her birth under normal circumstances but relying on a Dr if complications were to occur combined with the advanced knowledge that all of us have regarding even basic things like washing our hands to the circumstances of 100 years ago when everything was different not just the medical knowledge of doctors. 

Jay Elle --- 16 years ago -

I am so mad, I typed out a long response and then my internet connection was lost. :/ Phooey. Well basically Lacy, while im not sure of the death ration back then, but today the United States has the highest death rate among newborns and mothers(among industrialized nations). While in other industrialized nations midwifes and doulas are common and the death rate is low, here they attend less then 8% of births. I believe there is definitely a correlation. I thnk that a doctor should intervene if it is medically necessary, but more often then not interventions are not needed. They can even be harmful. Why would you opt for a c-section out of convenience? That is major surgery. 

saywhat?! --- 16 years ago -

Well since I don't have kids I obviously know nothing about this, but I read the entire article and I don't like how it kept referring to her childbirth as a "failure" and how Mayim from Blossom referred to her childbirth as a "failure" because she delivered her baby in a hospital instead of in her home. I think that anytime you deliver a baby whether or not you used an epidural or had a dam* mid-wife or a doula or a doctor doesn't matter..what matters is you deliver a healthy baby. To me that is a success and I'm just in shock they would call it a failure..how can it be a failure when you just delivered your child? I understand wanting things to go exactly as planned, but seriously these people should be thankful that they have healthy babies. 

Tits McGee --- 16 years ago -

Well basically Lacy, while im not sure of the death ration back then, but today the United States has the highest death rate among newborns and mothers(among industrialized nations). While in other industrialized nations midwifes and doulas are common and the death rate is low, here they attend less then 8% of births. I believe there is definitely a correlation

I didn't know that!
Okay, disregard my statement earlier.
But I really didn't know that. 

Jay Elle --- 16 years ago -

You would never have thought that, huh? You should watch The Business of Being Born. It's very eye opening. Doctors are trained to respond to emergency situations in child-birth, which is GREAT, im glad we have doctors for help when things go wrong. But a lot of times, those interventions aren't needed. 

ALEM --- 16 years ago -

I think it depends on the situation.

If i let my dr now control my labor for logan, i'd be preggo til 39 weeks. I'm scared already to see how big he really is (ash was 36 weeks and 8lbs i can't imagine if i went full term with her). I've already been admitted twice, once for preterm and the other night when they thought for sure he'd be here...now again i was there last night, contracting every 2-3 minutes on the dot, but only dialated to a 4 still....nope they sent me home after 30 minutes of being on monitors. I'm still having them too and the pain blows! 

Spork Fight --- 16 years ago -

i think a good balance is necessary... when i gave birth, i had a list of things i wanted my doc to know. (things i wanted to be allowed to do, music, husband helping etc.) when it came to the actual process, i relied on help from the doc. they are experienced in it, and i wasnt (first kid). i dont think just one person has to have control... its finding a balance :P 

Vod Kaknockers --- 16 years ago -

I think in most cases the mother should be in control. I know I was when I had A.

Once they admitted me they let me proceed with what I wanted and when I wanted it.
The only time they suggested anything was when I was 9 cm, 99% effaced, and contractions were lasting more then 2 mins and were about 45 seconds apart, then they just stopped.
They asked if I wanted them to give me Pitocin to get everything going again, I talked to hubby and we agreed to go that route. Pitocin didn't do anything for me, my labor was on hold for 3 hours, then all of a sudden it was back and in full force. 

sofaa --- 16 years ago -

Well... I'm not a doctor so I wouldn't know everything there is to know about childbirth. That's the doctor/midwife's job... I think it should be shared control for me personally but to each their own. 

petit oiseau --- 16 years ago -

Overall, I think it should be up to the doctor but they should also listen to the mother as well. 

O G docswife --- 16 years ago -

I recommend watching business of being born to everyone also. It will morethan likely change your mind about how this country views birth. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground