Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Christmas Question

who's talking here?

LauraLee 2
Mrs Patch 4
*All Smiles* 1
CourtesyFlush 2
Heather 1
That Stephanie 1
Megan B. 1
Braydens Mommy 1
sofaa 2
El Doosho 4
MandaBabyy 1
AJ*Tastefully Simple* 1
Spork Fight 1
LakerGirl 2
Colonel LizZoo 1
BadMomma 1
whatevergirlツ 3
Mommyof2boys 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Mommyof2boys --- 16 years ago -

Hi everyone just a quick question... Do you think it would be ok to send family members a "Wish list" for your children for christmas. Just to make it easier to buy for them...Help me out cause i dont know if i should or not. Thanks 

*All Smiles* --- 16 years ago -

I guess that depends. I probably wouldn't do it unless they asked for one. Then again for people like my mom or my SIL that I know are going to for sure by my kids presents I don't think they would be offended at all if I decided to send one before it was requested.

I think if you're hesitant to send one it's a sign that it might not be received well. Just wait for them to ask for a list. 

CourtesyFlush --- 16 years ago -

I guess that depends. I probably wouldn't do it unless they asked for one. Then again for people like my mom or my SIL that I know are going to for sure by my kids presents I don't think they would be offended at all if I decided to send one before it was requested.

I think if you're hesitant to send one it's a sign that it might not be received well. Just wait for them to ask for a list.


I agree. 

Braydens Mommy --- 16 years ago -

I just tell my mom over the phone...if anyone else needs to know what they are into or what they would like, they can ask her =) 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

Personally, I wouldn't ever do that. But that's just me. I don't believe in any "registries" either though. 

Mrs Patch --- 16 years ago -

I'm going to send my in-laws a wish list just to see if they manage to send something. On the other side of that token I am going to have to ask my side of the family to please not buy tons of things as the baby already has plenty. However, if they want to buy me some new tires... hehehe 

sofaa --- 16 years ago -

My family does that. I loove making wishlists for myself so I have an ongoing one on Facebook... not for other people to buy me stuff just for myself because I find it fun. But at holidays, my family says they use it to shop for me sometimes.

I have an aunt who thinks Christmas wishlists are selfish. I don't get that. If it's for someone who is buying you a gift anyway, I see no difference in that and answering them when they say "what do you want". 

Colonel LizZoo --- 16 years ago -

I think it's great, but only if they asked for one. Otherwise, it may seem presumptuous. 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

My family does that. I loove making wishlists for myself so I have an ongoing one on Facebook... not for other people to buy me stuff just for myself because I find it fun. But at holidays, my family says they use it to shop for me sometimes.

I have an aunt who thinks Christmas wishlists are selfish. I don't get that. If it's for someone who is buying you a gift anyway, I see no difference in that and answering them when they say "what do you want".


Riiigghhhtt

And I agree with your aunt 

sofaa --- 16 years ago -

Riiigghhhtt 


Why would I make it for other people in the middle of September? lol I meant I have it all year round and just add pictures when I find stuff I like. People have told me they enjoy looking at it and my family sometimes uses it as a shopping guide for my birthday/Christmas. I think I just repeated myself :P 

Mrs Patch --- 16 years ago -

Riiigghhhtt

lol

We have always made lists at Christmas for things, but that pretty much died down once we grew up and got married and moved on. 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -


We have always made lists at Christmas for things, but that pretty much died down once we grew up and got married and moved on.


As a kid, I could see it. As an adult, I would never do it. 

LakerGirl --- 16 years ago -

only if they asked for one. Otherwise, it may seem presumptuous.

Even if asked to make a list, it's not necessarily something that we want to teach our son. We didn't do wedding or baby registries either.

For our son's birthday party this year, we gave people the option of (rather than bringing a gift) donating to a non-profit organization that funds research for the neurological disorder that my son has. Our son has more toys/clothes than he could ever need, and most people seemed to love that idea. 

El Doosho --- 16 years ago -

Even if asked to make a list, it's not necessarily something that we want to teach our son. We didn't do wedding or baby registries either.

For our son's birthday party this year, we gave people the option of (rather than bringing a gift) donating to a non-profit organization that funds research for the neurological disorder that my son has. Our son has more toys/clothes than he could ever need, and most people seemed to love that idea.



*****EL DOOSHO stands and applauds***** 

Mrs Patch --- 16 years ago -

As a kid, I could see it. As an adult, I would never do it.

We did it as a tradition along w/ baking Christmas cookies and setting out the milk for Santa. Now that my nephew is a grown man lol it's not something we continued doing. This Christmas, however, I would like to know what kinds of things my sister (who is the one taking care of my mom full time) would like, but getting a "list" out of her is like pulling teeth. 

BadMomma --- 16 years ago -

Do you think it would be ok to send family members a "Wish list" for your children for christmas

absolutely not - i would be speachless if i got that in the mail

but then again i also put "please no gifts" on my kids birthday party invites - they really dont need anything (edit and before anyone jumps on my case, the boys do get gifts but from parents, grandparents etc) 

AJ*Tastefully Simple* --- 16 years ago -

I have an amazon wishlist but that is for me to mark things I want t buy eventually.
However, my step mom just asked about my birthday so that is where I directed her. 

MandaBabyy --- 16 years ago -

My family does that. I loove making wishlists for myself so I have an ongoing one on Facebook... not for other people to buy me stuff just for myself because I find it fun. But at holidays, my family says they use it to shop for me sometimes.


I have an Amazon wishlist, too... buttt I don't have it on my Facebook. I just keep it.. I always say I want something and then I think it over for a few weeks and if I reaaallly want it, then I go to my wishlist and buy it. :D 

CourtesyFlush --- 16 years ago -

My mom and FIL ask for them so we send 2 ideas for each. We don't make a huge list or anything. I really don't like to do tons of gifts for Christmas anyways. We usually do one big gift, a couple of smaller things, and then stockings with little goodies. 

Mrs Patch --- 16 years ago -

stockings

For us the stockings are much more fun than the presents. We have such a blast seeing who got what inside theirs. Of course they are mostly gag gift kind of stockings. After stockings we go to the movies and then come back for round 2 of Christmas dinner. 

LakerGirl --- 16 years ago -


For us the stockings are much more fun than the presents. We have such a blast seeing who got what inside theirs. Of course they are mostly gag gift kind of stockings.


Same here. :) 

LauraLee --- 16 years ago -

I think if someone asks for suggestions then a wish list is perfectly fine.

My family sits down every year Thanksgiving night and write our letters to Santa. My Mom and Dad use these lists to buy for the family ( I'm the oldest of 6, and there's 10 g-kids so its a BIG family)

My in-laws on the other hand want DETAILED lists. They want item numbers and exact things. To me this takes a lot of the surprise out of the day. 

whatevergirlツ --- 16 years ago -

I don't believe in any "registries" either though.

I hate registries too!

Here is why I dislike registries or lists for that matter. I actually like shopping and finding the "perfect" gift for someone. Sometimes its finding something great that person would never have thought of themselves. To me it takes time and thought to find "the gift" for someone. A list or registry takes all that away. But then again I am a "thought behind it" girl.

Maybe I didn't make any sense with my ramble. =0) 

Megan B. --- 16 years ago -

When I was younger like 5 up till middle school I made wish list either wrote them down and gave them to everyone or once internet came out I emailed them! lol But now I just write what I want down and when someone ask I have it handy!! 

Spork Fight --- 16 years ago -

I always felt weird asking for things... I don't know, presents to me are things that are optional, and if I receive them its nice to see what they picked out. I like it even more if its something they made :) 

whatevergirlツ --- 16 years ago -

See I am simple. I will take a pound of Murphys and a bottle of huckleberry wine. lol. My husband can drop a few $$ on my gift but for the rest it just seems silly. 

Heather --- 16 years ago -

My mom is an avid black friday shopper, so before thanksgiving she asks us for lists. We (the kids) usually ask for pretty practical things. The first year I moved out I asked for a microwave lol. And then she does little small gifts. 

LauraLee --- 16 years ago -

Here is why I dislike registries or lists for that matter. I actually like shopping and finding the "perfect" gift for someone. Sometimes its finding something great that person would never have thought of themselves. To me it takes time and thought to find "the gift" for someone. A list or registry takes all that away. But then again I am a "thought behind it" girl.


That's why I don't like how my inlaws do it. I don't want to tell you what I want. I want you to know me enough to get something you know I'll like. 

That Stephanie --- 16 years ago -

Last year was our first Christmas away from family. Everyone just sent me money and I did the shopping so that they didn't have to pay for shipping etc. 

whatevergirlツ --- 16 years ago -

I want you to know me enough to get something you know I'll like.

Funny you mention that. I feel the same way. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
children
help
parenting

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground