Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Which dog would be right?

who's talking here?

Cayla 1
Jillian 1
Me+3 14
FixDaPix 2
Princess B 1
FurMama 1
sofaa 4
mommas boys 1
*Sarah H* 1
~AvA*LOVE~ 1
MandaBabyy 1
Carolyn Brown CMT 8
PAJ14 1
Tits McGee 1
TaDa 4
Hazel Eyed Beauty 1
Starshine79 5
Minnie 1
Boots 2
whatevergirlツ 1
Danielle 1
Cierra 1
DoctorDonna 1
Juliet Bravo 2
PunkinPunkin 1
LovinOurLife 1
TanyaB 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Me+3 --- 15 years ago -

So, hubby and I are thinking of getting a dog for my dad for protection not anytime soon but maybe in 6-9 mos or so.

Right now we are looking into breeds but I figured with the amt of dog lovers on here, this would be a GREAT resource!

What we're after is not necessarily an a guard dog, but more like an alarm dog- (thank you other dog thread for teaching me the difference)

It would have to be a puppy that my dad could bond with and train and we are thinking mid sized/smaller large dog that would be EXCELLENT with small children and would would try to protect him with its own life if it came down to it- does that make sense? I am more looking for something that could alert him to an intruder and know that unless we get him larger big dog actual protection probably isn't going to happen. I could be wrong though? I am not all that familiar with any of the larger dog breeds.

Right now a Bulldog (because I've always wanted one) or a St Bernard seems to be the frontrunner- but again, we are totally NOT set on any breed so I would love to hear your advice... 

TaDa --- 15 years ago -

A mutt. 

sofaa --- 15 years ago -

Dobermans are very protective. 

Juliet Bravo --- 15 years ago -

My dachshund is protective =X 

Me+3 --- 15 years ago -

Sofaa I really wanted to get him one of those but he and my mum had one before and when it died some 40 plus years ago it was pretty traumatic for him.

That was the one breed we are staying away from for memories sake :( 

Boots --- 15 years ago -

We have a german shephed very protective but around other dogs he's a wimp lol he also will bark and someone and if they chase him he'll run hahaha my big scary dog pfff... 

Me+3 --- 15 years ago -

Also, it would have to be good as being a solo dog, buying 2 dogs would be too expensive, and I don't love my dad that much ;) 

sofaa --- 15 years ago -

It's really going to come down to the training anyway. 

whatevergirlツ --- 15 years ago -

German Shepard hands down. 

Cayla --- 15 years ago -

We have a mutt.

He would kill before he was killed but he is pretty good with my kids. 

Starshine79 --- 15 years ago -

Mastiff. Gentle, protective, quick learner, lazy, family pet. As good as it gets... :) 

mommas boys --- 15 years ago -

Dobermans are very protective

that's what we have she's half dobie and half grey hound. she's an awesome dog. any stranger that comes to the door she is barking. And when we brought our boys home from the hospital she would sleep right by their bassinet or crib. 

Me+3 --- 15 years ago -

I will have to look into German Shepards- they're pretty common back home so that might be an easy one to track down. 

sofaa --- 15 years ago -

My inlaws have a Mastiff! He's soo gentle and slow but his size would scare of a lot of people and he's good about barking at people who come near the house.

I have a mix-breed and he's good about barking at intruders. He's never done anything more than that though and I've never thought of him a "guard dog". I remember a cop telling me that you people shouldn't assume their pets make for good guard dogs... that they have to be trained properly for that. He said they tend to bark when we're home but not when we're away lol 

Starshine79 --- 15 years ago -

The Mastiff breed has a desired temperament, which is reflected in all formal standards and historical descriptions.Though calm and affectionate to its master, it is capable of protection. If an unfamiliar person approaches near the Mastiff's perceived territory or its master, ideally, it will immediately position itself between its master and the stranger. If the approaching person is perceived as a threat, the Mastiff may take immediate defensive action. Mastiffs will rarely attack an introducer or perceived threat (unless cornered or severely provoked) and instead will generally pin and immobilize the individual. Mastiffs are normally good natured, calm, easygoing, and surprisingly gentle for their size. It is a well-mannered house pet, provided it gets daily exercise and activity. The Mastiff is typically an extremely loyal breed, exceptionally devoted to its family and good with children and small dogs. 

Princess B --- 15 years ago -

Dobermans are very protective

This is what we have and he is a dork lol. Maybe a Jack Russell Terrier? They are small and my grandfather has one but she means bidnaz. 

Carolyn Brown CMT --- 15 years ago -

I have an Olde English Bulldog. The breed is a combination between an English Bulldog, American Bulldog, Bull Mastiff and Pit Bill. He is larger than English Bulldogs, and from what I can tell he is almost as big as my neighbors American Bulldog. He is 85 pounds full grown. He is a very good alarm dog but will normally calm down if you tell him "it's ok". I've never seen him attack anyone so I don't know if he'd be good for "actual" protection, but I think if it came down to it he would protect me. He sleeps facing the door and doesn't like to be away from me so I think he really does want to protect me. The only problem is he was a handful when he was a puppy (and still can be if the doorbell rings... it takes physical restraint to keep him from tackling the person at the door. Probably still the protection thing, but it can be difficult). I dont know if your dad is elderly, but getting the dog from a puppy might be challenging unless you are there often to help. 

Me+3 --- 15 years ago -

I was looking up Mastiffs- they are enormous! It might be good for him though, I will look into it.

Just in case anyone is wondering we did tell him we were searching for a companion/protection pet for him and he was okay with it :) 

Carolyn Brown CMT --- 15 years ago -

Sorry for the massive paragraph :) 

*Sarah H* --- 15 years ago -

Just in case anyone is wondering we did tell him we were searching for a companion/protection pet for him and he was okay with it :) 

Your dad is so freaking cute. My dad totally loved him too. I can totally imagine him with a bulldog lol 

Danielle --- 15 years ago -

German Shepherds are awesome at family home protection with little training. Also if you just want an "alarm" dog, most breeds will do. Border Collies are known to bark and alert to any new stranger or sound. 

PAJ14 --- 15 years ago -

Wow! I agree about the Mastiff being a great pic BUT what does your dad want to pay in dog food bills each month!? Yikes! :) There are a lot of factors to consider. Does he have the space for a mastiff or do you think he is better off with something under the 100 lb mark?

It's really going to come down to the training anyway.

I agree:) 

Me+3 --- 15 years ago -

Carolyn- my dad is definitely getting on in years he is almost 70 so I worry about him. He is no spring chicken anymore and has some health issues and is more than aware of it.

He is not in his house alone, but I think this would be good for him. 

Starshine79 --- 15 years ago -

I was looking up Mastiffs- they are enormous! It might be good for him though, I will look into it.

Eh, it's like owning a pony. lol The worst part about them is the drool. I take mine on a 15-20 minute walk and they are dead asleep for the rest of the day. Such bums. Every time we have people over they talk about how they wish their dogs were as lazy as mine. People who don't know them are afraid, and those who do know they are big teddy bears. I can't even tell you how true it is that they position themselves between their owner and strangers. Mine do it all the time. lol 

TaDa --- 15 years ago -

Wow! I agree about the Mastiff being a great pic BUT what does your dad want to pay in dog food bills each month!? Yikes! :) There are a lot of factors to consider. Does he have the space for a mastiff or do you think he is better off with something under the 100 lb mark?

Mastiffs will cost you a grip in medical bills too they tend to have health problems like bulldogs.

You should take him to the shelter have have him pick a dog out that way he gets the one he bonds with. 

Starshine79 --- 15 years ago -

Wow! I agree about the Mastiff being a great pic BUT what does your dad want to pay in dog food bills each month!? Yikes! :) There are a lot of factors to consider. Does he have the space for a mastiff or do you think he is better off with something under the 100 lb mark?

Most don't eat more than a Lab because they are prone to getting overweight easily. And contrary to popular belief, they don't need much room. They aren't very active dogs. 

Me+3 --- 15 years ago -

Sarah, I can too. But that is more me wanting him to have one, I think ;) Plus, I think he kind of looks like one, so maybe that is why I like them so much?

My dad has heaps of space for a big dog and the food bills are good, my dad is a softie and would feed it leftovers in addition to what it is supposed to eat so I'm guessing I will need something with pretty good skin and no history of issues.

I just worry with him being older and indefensible somewhat. I know he doesn't like small dogs though, so a larger one is a must for him! 

Me+3 --- 15 years ago -

TaDa- We are looking for a purebred dog that way we could get somewhat of a health guarantee and that we would have a good idea on the size, possible medical issues et al. He is in another country so we would either pick it out and let him visit it and give the final word, or get it over here and have it shipped back with him on his next visit.

It is a tricky one, but my dad wont' do anything unless he is made to. lol. 

Carolyn Brown CMT --- 15 years ago -

my dad is definitely getting on in years he is almost 70

I would just be diligent about training him from the start then, before his weight gets to be a potential issue. If he's well behaved then it won't be a problem. I think thats true with any of the breeds mentioned here though.

As far as health problems, Olde English have a longer muzzle and can breathe easier than English. Mine has had a few skin problems but knock on wood they are gone now. They do snore though, so be warned! :) 

Boots --- 15 years ago -

And large breeds are prone to hip problems etc. Umm..bull dogs are extremly hyper my father in law has one she gets her nails trimmed all the time they are like razors lol 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground