Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: is it okay to have a birthday party and not serve any food or drinks?

who's talking here?

yvette 1
Mrs Patch 11
Janice 1
Princess B 1
sofaa 2
Lavender is Good 3
Trixie St James 1
MomOf2inCali 3
hailstorm 1
MandaBabyy 1
LakerGirl 7
Hokey*Pokey 2
Trace 3
Rebecca 11
Hollyer Than Thou 1
Brown Eyed Girl 1
Mrs T Goin to Jail 2
Mrs Westray 1
Sleep thief 3
Charlies mama 1
purpleismyfavorite 1
skysmommy 5
BadMomma2 1
MissTexas 1
Texas9 1
Scrappy 11
Vivacious St0rm 1
ChickenButt 1
CluelessWonder 1
LullabiesButterflies 3
foxed 1
LilShutterbug 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: is it okay to have a birthday party and not serve any food or drinks?

Went to a friend's kid's party where nothing was served. It was basically, we all got together, sat in the living room while the kids played outside and there was absolutely nothing to eat or drink for the guests. I kinda feel like the whole thing was just an excuse to get her kid some presents. So I'm wondering if I'm being unreasonable in thinking that it's not okay to invite people to a "party" but it not really be a "party." Oh I should add, there was a cake...which was cut after all presents were opened.

Yes Vote
 
 7.4% (7)
No Vote
 
 90.5% (86)
Maybe Vote
 
 2.1% (2)
Other Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
Sleep thief --- 15 years ago -

Went to a friend's kid's party where nothing was served. It was basically, we all got together, sat in the living room while the kids played outside and there was absolutely nothing to eat or drink for the guests.

I kinda feel like the whole thing was just an excuse to get her kid some presents.

So I'm wondering if I'm being unreasonable in thinking that it's not okay to invite people to a "party" but it not really be a "party."

Oh I should add, there was a cake...which was cut after all presents were opened. 

sofaa --- 15 years ago -

Nope. They should have just made it a potluck if they didn't want to or couldn't really afford to provide enough food/drinks for everyone. 

LakerGirl --- 15 years ago -

Pretty tacky. I've also never been to a party where presents were opened at the party. 

Hokey*Pokey --- 15 years ago -

Even when people come to my house just to hang out, I always offer a soda or bottled water or something 

sofaa --- 15 years ago -

Pretty tacky. I've also never been to a party where presents were opened at the party. 


Every kids party I went to did. I loved seeing people open what I got them! 

Hokey*Pokey --- 15 years ago -

Pretty tacky. I've also never been to a party where presents were opened at the party.


I've never been to a kids' party where the presents weren't opened during the party 

Mrs Patch --- 15 years ago -

Hell no it's not ok! Neither is asking your guests to bring their own food. It's a different matter altogether if it's deemed a potluck for a community celebration, but for your own family member's birthday then no - you need to provide for them. 

Mrs Westray --- 15 years ago -

I was always raised that if i have guests i provide food and drinks.
And no i have never been to a bday party where there werent any.
All the parties i went to as a kid the presents were opened during the party. So everyone could say what you got. But usually after the cake. 

Texas9 --- 15 years ago -

Pretty tacky. I've also never been to a party where presents were opened at the party.


I've never been to a kids' party where the presents weren't opened during the party 


x2. Gifts are always opened at parties while the guests are there...the ones we have been to at least. 

LakerGirl --- 15 years ago -

That's interesting. All the parties we've been to have been fairly large and usually at party places where the staff collect the gifts for the family to take home later. Those places are limited with their time, which is I guess why they do it that way. I don't know. We say "no gifts" on my son's party invites, so we've never had to deal with it. 

Mrs Patch --- 15 years ago -

Maybe she didn't know any better, and at least offered a cake but I personally would not consider that a "party". 

Trixie St James --- 15 years ago -

Wow that's just.. sad. I'd prolly ask where the food was, and once answered with like a "no we dont have any", I'd grab my kids and take them to McD's. 

LakerGirl --- 15 years ago -

Isn't it just basic etiquette that if you invite guests to your home, you provide them with food and drinks? At least snacks or something?

eta: I guess maybe they thought the cake was enough...? 

Sleep thief --- 15 years ago -

[i]Isn't it just basic etiquette that if you invite guests to your home, you provide them with food and drinks? At least snacks or something? 
[/i]

This was my thinking too!!! 

LilShutterbug --- 15 years ago -

I always provide at least light snacks (in addition to cake and drinks). To me, its just not natural to have people gathered around and not feed them...but I grew up where yo offer someone something to eat or drink when they enter your house, even if they are just staying a few minutes! Southern hospitality at its finest :D 

Brown Eyed Girl --- 15 years ago -

Beyond tacky!!! How can you have a birthday party with nothing?? You can't say it's that expensive. If we were low on money my momma made this: a Homemade birthday cake, punch, some hog dogs and chips. We had some cheap games and little cheap prizes. It worked. We never knew the diffrence. 

Scrappy --- 15 years ago -

I think you should feed the guests and give goody bags to the kids. It's the least you can do when people bring your child gifts. The goody bags or goody cake ( hahaha inserted a self promotion there hehehe) are so all the kids that come get a little something too. 

Hollyer Than Thou --- 15 years ago -

At my son's party coming up soon, we will at least be having sodas, punch, cake and ice cream. Geez. 

MandaBabyy --- 15 years ago -

I don't even have kids but have been to several parties for my friend's kiddos.. I agree. I mean, if you go over for two hours, maybe longer.. do people expect that you're not thirsty, at the very least?! 

LakerGirl --- 15 years ago -

goody bags

I had so much fun making goody bags. I won't even share how much I spent on them though! lol 

Scrappy --- 15 years ago -

I have always had my kids open their presents at their bday parties.....never heard of anyone having a party where their kids didn't. We do it at the end of the party so none of the kids fight over the presents. I would think everyone would want to see the look on the kiddos faces when they opened the gift they brought. 

Rebecca --- 15 years ago -

I think that on the base things have gotten a bit crazy, I have been to several parties (e-3-e-6) where the parents tell me that they spent 300+ on the party.

When I was growing up we always just did a simple cake and the drinks were coffee, tea, water (from the tap) and sometimes a jug of koolaid.

But the exception to this is if your party was during a meal time then everyone presumed you would have a meal. So say the party was 11-1pm then they would have lunch, but if it was 1-3 then you eat before you come and presume they are just having cake.

As far as gifts though we always just bought something small, I am always in shock when I go to some of the b-day parties on the base and the non family guests have brought presents that are easily $20-$40..... I always just bring a $5 ish gift unless the family are close friends and then max is $20 

Scrappy --- 15 years ago -

20-$40

We always buy gifts in that price range lol. 

Mrs Patch --- 15 years ago -

We always buy gifts in that price range lol.

So do we. I can't imagine having a party and not serving a meal. We tend to go ALL OUT though. 

Rebecca --- 15 years ago -

I can't imagine having a party and not serving a meal


Why would you serve a meal if it is not a meal time though? 

Scrappy --- 15 years ago -

Mrs patch us too. It's either at a place like chuck e cheese where we get the package and all the kids invited get the works and the adults get food or we have a BBQ and have burgers and hot dogs, chips,cake, drinks the whole shebang. 

Scrappy --- 15 years ago -

Rebecca --- 39 sec ago - quote - flag comment - hide comments
I can't imagine having a party and not serving a meal


Why would you serve a meal if it is not a meal time though? 


It may be a southern thing but I grew up where you serve a meal when you have a get together so our parties are always around lunch time or dinner time. 

Mrs Patch --- 15 years ago -

Why would you serve a meal if it is not a meal time though?

Why would you not? *shudders*

It's just not customary in our culture to not offer food/drinks. We were always taught that your guests, regardless of the "time of day" should be offered refreshments. 

Mrs Patch --- 15 years ago -

Scrappy - I am a believer that the whole thing starts w/ the invitation. We like to plan things down to the last detail. 

Lavender is Good --- 15 years ago -

I voted no because I think it is impolite to not offer guests in your home something to drink. Anything beyond that is probably extra though if the party isn't long and isn't during a meal time. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground