I have a question regarding the Confederate flag. I grew up in the West and spent about 9 months in South Carolina for college. That's the extent of my exposure to Southern culture. So I see the Confederate flag as a symbol of a disliking, possibly hatred, of Blacks and even perhaps a wish that the Confederate Army had been victorious in the Civil War. To put it succinctly, I view it as a vile representation of a vile way of thinking. But I see them displayed on cars and beach towels and all kinds of things and I am wondering if there is something I am missing, or are these people openly displaying their disdain for an entire race? If you are one of the people that uses a Confederate flag for a decoration in some way, why do you do it? Is there another meaning behind it? Hopefully this makes sense. My husband always says pretty bad things when he sees a Confederate flag on something and I can't help but think bad things about a person who displays one.
I'm from Florida originally but lived in NC for quite a while. That flag is every where there as well. Even flying from a flag pole in front of people's houses. I'm not entirely sure why to be honest.
The house across the street from my cousins school is va has one flying. I've also seen them a lot on base... Painted on to tailgates etc. Idk I wouldnt display one that's for sure
It has something to do with "southern pride" (like the morals and way of life more common to the south) for a lot of southerners, as in it's original meaning before civil war. (Similar to the swastika (sp?) Since most people know it as a symbol that supports slavery I agree that it is pretty tactless to display it publicly
The flag is what these men died under, to keep their land, it has nothing to do with color. At the time of the civil war, the south had their own president and the north wanted to unite the north and south together, under the north and their president, Abraham Lincoln. the south had better crops and land for development and the biggest of all the north wanted to build the rail roads through the south. The south wanted to have its own independent from the north.
But I see them displayed on cars and beach towels and all kinds of things and I am wondering if there is something I am missing, or are these people openly displaying their disdain for an entire race? If you are one of the people that uses a Confederate flag for a decoration in some way, why do you do it? Is there another meaning behind it?
I am from NC and though I don't really get all into the whole "rebel flag" thing, I know for 100% fact the MAJORITY of people I knew from High School were just redneck boys who see the rebel flag as a Southern Pride thing. I don't know why people view it as a hatred thing because not all Southerners even owned slaves. I took a US History class a few months ago and less than 200 people out of the 5 million or so who lived in the south were the ones who owned hundreds of slaves. The rebel flag does NOT = slavery or hatred of blacks. It represents the Southern states in a historical pride.
That would be like someone hanging an Iraqi flag here and we just assume they are terrorists.
My neighbours husband (who's from Maine) thinks he from the south and trys to show-off it by having the confederate flag everywhere. But he is racest and will openly tell you he is. I'm from Texas and I'm not even like that I don't hang out with him because of how ignorant he is about it and I don't want my children to learn that life style.
My neighbours husband (who's from Maine) thinks he from the south and trys to show-off it by having the confederate flag everywhere. But he is racest and will openly tell you he is.
See, he has no idea what the rebel flag means. What a turd.
NotPhased that was my point. People assume if you have a rebel flag you are a racist. Not all Southerners are racist.
When we lived in 29 Palms my BIL worked at the Motel 6 and he said one night he had to call the police because some drunk Marines were harassing a family from the middle east calling them terrorists and basically harassing them to the point where the woman was in tears and the man was trying to get his money back. It was horrible. People just assume things because a small number of people are extreme that everyone is that way because they look the same, or because they are from the same place. Maybe that makes more sense.
because you can not support both the civil war which divided our nation, and support our nation at the same time.
I am going to assume you never met any of the redneck boys I went to high school with lmao. Ew. They were so ridiculously patriotic it was stupid. I think people don't understand when they haven't seen it first hand. Like I said, I am not a rebel flag wearer or whatever, but I know that the people I personally know who are definitely are not racist and they are very patriotic.
When we lived in 29 Palms my BIL worked at the Motel 6 and he said one night he had to call the police because some drunk Marines were harassing a family from the middle east calling them terrorists and basically harassing them to the point where the woman was in tears and the man was trying to get his money back. It was horrible. People just assume things because a small number of people are extreme that everyone is that way because they look the same, or because they are from the same place. Maybe that makes more sense.
The flag is what these men died under, to keep their land, it has nothing to do with color. At the time of the civil war, the south had their own president and the north wanted to unite the north and south together, under the north and their president, Abraham Lincoln. the south had better crops and land for development and the biggest of all the north wanted to build the rail roads through the south. The south wanted to have its own independent from the north.
X2 I've never viewed the confederate flag as a racial thing, it's about southern pride. I can see how some people who are ignorant would use it trying to be hateful and racist, but that isn't what the flag itself stands for.
That would be like someone hanging an Iraqi flag here and we just assume they are terrorists.
Bad example -_- Iraqis are NOT terrorist...
Not a bad example because not everyone that displays a confederate flag is a racist. Both of ignorant things some people believe.
I am from NC and though I don't really get all into the whole "rebel flag" thing, I know for 100% fact the MAJORITY of people I knew from High School were just redneck boys who see the rebel flag as a Southern Pride thing. I don't know why people view it as a hatred thing because not all Southerners even owned slaves. I took a US History class a few months ago and less than 200 people out of the 5 million or so who lived in the south were the ones who owned hundreds of slaves. The rebel flag does NOT = slavery or hatred of blacks. It represents the Southern states in a historical pride.
Agree!! I actually find it kind of offensive that people assume that if you display a confederate flag you must be racist. That is just extremely ignorant. Should I assume that if you display a California flag you're an extreme liberal homosexual who hates the military?? No.
It's not just the South. I hung out with a lot of redneck types in high school in Canada and many wore confederate flag belt buckles or had the flag displayed in the home and so on. I often called them out on it. I think it's disrespectful and most people I confronted didn't even know what it meant they'd just say "it's a country (as in the music) thing".
they are hypocrites and ignorant then, and had no clue what they are he hawing about.
Maybe. I don't really care how ignorant they are. I didn't marry one of them lol. All I know is that for southerners it is not a racial thing which means more in my eyes than what people outside of the south think it is. You cannot will someone to be a racist because of a flag.
im a cali girl, when ever i see cali natives hanging or wearing them i associate it with them being racist. period the end. same goes for southerners your apart of a nation now you lost the war over 100 years ago GET OVER IT MOVE ON.
I can Honestly tell you that everyone I have meet that's from the south that has the flag hanging or whatever they are racest and will openly admit it to you. I have not meet a single person from the south that didn't mean it in a racest way.
green chick- here is an interesting study:interesting
That is interesting. I wonder how many of them would vote for a woman either. White, or not. Southern people are traditional sometimes and stuck in their ways. I am not saying that makes them right. I am just saying it does not make them racist, or discriminatory against women. Just traditionalists.
Study, or no study. I am just telling you my personal experience which means more in my eyes than a study of random people. I know more racists here that are from CA than I know in the south. Go figure.
Agree!! I actually find it kind of offensive that people assume that if you display a confederate flag you must be racist. That is just extremely ignorant. Should I assume that if you display a California flag you're an extreme liberal homosexual who hates the military?? No.
That would be like someone hanging an Iraqi flag here and we just assume they are terrorists.
I think these two statements are a little off. If someone was flying a South Carolina, Georgia, or any other southern state flag I would not assume them to be racist at all because that is just symbolizing where they're from, just like an Iraqi or California flag. I won't assume they're anything unless I meet them because where you're from doesn't mean anything. BUT, if someone were to be flying a flag for some extremist Islamic group I will assume they are extremists, or if someone is flying a rainbow flag, I will assume they support gay rights because both those flags don't say where they're from, but rather a social/political view. In this same way, a Confederate flag was used in the Civil war for a side that is more recognized as being slaveholders and those that didn't view blacks as fully human, but rather 2/3. So, it's definitely has social/political vibes that you really can't deny.
Lol I automatically think of my family. I think I own one shirt with it on it (I wear for cleaning but I am not racist in any way!) that was a gift last year for Christmas. The way I was raised is it's a heritage thing, southern pride. Yeah there are alot that take it to extremes and use other interpretations, but where I'm from we seen it differently. Hell there were a few blacks at our school that had the belt buckles and car decals!