Pendleton Underground
The heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Pendleton bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Pendleton Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: What would you do? Ebay question

who's talking here?

Mrs Mamas 6
Donny 2
petit oiseau 1
sofaa 1
CivMP 2
Strawberry 1
Green Chick 2
Trace 1
APPLE 3
Basia 1
Whitness Protection Team Betty 2
xVivaLaDollx 1
whatevergirl2 2
Canine Comander 1
betty or veronica 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: What would you do? Ebay question

So I recently purchased an item on Ebay where the seller says it's 100% authentic. This seller is a "Power Seller" with over 2000 feedbacks at 99% positive. I got the item and it's fake...it's a VERY good replica but fake according to the store. Anyway so I opened a case and the seller immediately offered me a refund but I know they have a ton more of the same item listed which I can only assume to be fake as well. Do I leave negative feedback for the seller so others can see she is selling counterfeit items? Or not leave any feedback? I'm not leaving positive feedback as this was definitely not a positive buy.

Negative feedback Vote
 
 88.6% (39)
No feedback Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
Other Vote
 
 11.4% (5)
Mrs Mamas --- 15 years ago -

So I recently purchased an item on Ebay where the seller says it's 100% authentic. This seller is a "Power Seller" with over 2000 feedbacks at 99% positive. I got the item and it's fake...it's a VERY good replica but fake according to the store. Anyway so I opened a case and the seller immediately offered me a refund but I know they have a ton more of the same item listed which I can only assume to be fake as well. Do I leave negative feedback for the seller so others can see she is selling counterfeit items? Or not leave any feedback? I'm not leaving positive feedback as this was definitely not a positive buy. 

Green Chick --- 15 years ago -

Leave negative feedback. I always look at the specific negatives to see whether they were legitimate or not. I look at those more than I look at the happy ones even with sellers who have high percentage of positives.

eta: it was not as described so you have the right to leave the negative feedback without feeling guilty :) 

xVivaLaDollx --- 15 years ago -

Get your refund and then leave a negative feedback. 

Whitness Protection Team Betty --- 15 years ago -

I would leave neutral feedback saying that the item was fake but you were refunded. 

Trace --- 15 years ago -

I would wait until you get your refund... but i would also leave negative feedback. 

Mrs Mamas --- 15 years ago -

The seller has WAY more positive feedback than negative. In the last month the only 2 negative feedbacks was that the items ran out so the seller couldn't ship. It's crazy but I'm 100% certain ALL the items this lady has sold are counterfeit...VERY good ones but counterfeits nonetheless. Makes me sad to know (according to the feedback #) that a lot of people are walking around with counterfeits :-( 

whatevergirl2 --- 15 years ago -

Tell the truth. Item was determined fake. Seller was quick about refunding money. Communication was good. 

petit oiseau --- 15 years ago -

Get your refund and then leave a negative feedback. 

I agree with this. If you were able to check and find out that the item was fake, the seller should have been able to as well. 

Mrs Mamas --- 15 years ago -

I'm not trying to leave negative feedback to get revenge b/c at the end of the day I AM getting a refund but she has so many more auctions listed that I don't want someone else to get bamboozled too. 

Canine Comander --- 15 years ago -

I would leave neutral feedback saying that the item was fake but you were refunded.

x2 

CivMP --- 15 years ago -

I would leave neutral feedback saying that the item was fake but you were refunded.

x3 

whatevergirl2 --- 15 years ago -

You can select neutral too. It's neither good nor bad. 

APPLE --- 15 years ago -

I would leave neutral feedback saying that the item was fake but you were refunded.


Why? She was wronged. The seller is clearly banking on buyers believing the feedback, and her word. No one should sell items take are counterfeit and claim they are real. 

sofaa --- 15 years ago -

Negative if they are advertising as it being authentic.

A lot of Ebay sellers do that with nail polish like OPI. So lame. 

Green Chick --- 15 years ago -

You can select neutral too. It's neither good nor bad.

I would hesitate to leave neutral unless the lady REALLY didn't know she was selling a fake. If I thought it was a truly honest mistake that she posted it was authentic and it wasn't then I would post neutral.

I would go with negative only because people will pay more attention to the negatives. That is why feedback is there. She can still say "Seller refunded, communication excellent, but item is a replica - not as described"

Accidents are forgivable, but I would bet the seller knows exactly what she is doing. 

Whitness Protection Team Betty --- 15 years ago -

Why?

True it's not right that the item was fake but she was refunded. Potential buyers will still see it and ebay looks at that bad too. 

Donny --- 15 years ago -

Could it simply be the seller honestly didn't know it was a fake?

I'd try sending an email first to the seller suggesting they edit their other sales to denote the item is a knock-off and see if they do. If they do and you get your refund i'd call it a wash and move on.

If the seller keeps listing the item as real, i'd leave negative feedback to warn other sellers. 

Mrs Mamas --- 15 years ago -

I guess what makes me doubt myself is this seller has over 2000 feedbacks w/ 99& positive...how could THAT many people get ripped off and not know?! It's one thing if she was just selling this one thing but she has multiple listings of the same item so I doubt only mine is fake. I think I'm going to go with negative and say I was refunded but item was a counterfeit. AFTER I get my refund of course :-) 

Mrs Mamas --- 15 years ago -

If the seller keeps listing the item as real, i'd leave negative feedback to warn other sellers. 

I guess I'm more like "how do they NOT know?" if they have so many of the same items listed. But I will take your advice and send her a message to see how she replies. When I messaged her asking for a refund because my bag was a counterfeit she didn't reply until I opened a case with Ebay. Then she immediately replied saying she'd full refund me but didn't address the counterfeit claim. 

APPLE --- 15 years ago -

What was it? Care to post a pic?
Unfortunately because you are saying she has several items, I have to believe she knows they are fake. Its one thing if it was a resale and she was told the item was real. But one has to know where they get there bulk items from. Several companies don't sell to wholesales. 

APPLE --- 15 years ago -

When I messaged her asking for a refund because my bag was a counterfeit she didn't reply until I opened a case with Ebay. Then she immediately replied saying she'd full refund me but didn't address the counterfeit claim.
test


She knows! Someone else would've addressed it. 

Basia --- 15 years ago -

I would say exactly what happened in the feedback. Even if she didn't know it was fake. That just means she doesn't actually know if others are real. 

Strawberry --- 15 years ago -

I would wait until you get the refund, then you should leave the negative feedback 

CivMP --- 15 years ago -

You can also notify EBAY that she is selling knock-offs...

I once picked up a box of 40 nice knives... for about $20.00.. easy to turn them over for a little profit... I got a note from another ebayer,,, they were FAKES... i gave them all away. 

Mrs Mamas --- 15 years ago -

It was a Longchamp tote bag. I accidently left a can of OFF! bug spray in my other tote and I guess it sprayed at some point onto my bag, sat in there for 2 days and MELTED part of the inside( 

Donny --- 15 years ago -

Could very well be she's got so much positive feedback because like you stated they are very good knock-offs.

If the price is good i'm sure many people realize this and simply don't care they are buying a knockoff if it looks real and saves them money. 

betty or veronica --- 15 years ago -

I agree with Donny - if the price is good and it looks authentic, then people will buy it for those two reasons alone. Most people will never run into a designer handbag rep from Bloomingdales, so it's just the buyer's little replica secret. If the seller is advertising them as authentic, well, that is a problem and you can contact ebay and let them know the story and they will look into it. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Pendleton Underground